Submission for reviewer

Reviewer's Name*

Email*

Affliation*

Title of Manuscript*

Manuscript ID*

1. The topic is important and relevant for publication*
YesNo

Comments

2. The work presented in the manuscript is original*
YesNo

Comments

3. The manuscript uses sufficient references*
YesNo

Comments

4. The manuscript uses appropriate language and styles*
YesNo

Comments

5. The title of the manuscript is appropriate*
YesNo

Comments

6. The order of presentation is satisfactory*
YesNo

Comments

7. The abstract adequately summarizes the content of the manuscript*
YesNo

Comments

8. The introduction is adequately developed*
YesNo

Comments

9. The problem described in the manuscript is clearly stated*
YesNo

Comments

10. The adopted methodology described in the manuscript is sound*
YesNo

Comments

11. The findings of this manuscript are correctly interpreted*
YesNo

Comments

12. The quality of figures and illustrations is acceptable for publications*
YesNo

Comments

13. The manuscript does not dwell on any sensitive issues*
YesNo

Comments

Comments to Author*

Confidential Comments to Editor*

Recommendation*
Accept as it isMinor correctionMajor correctionReject

Attachment